Posts Tagged ‘fear’

#6: Taking or taking care.

***This is the sixth of a series of posts based on a book I’m reading for a class called Connections in Religious and Ecological Education entitled Holy Ground: A Gathering of Voices on Caring for Creation. The chapter is “Two Towns, Two Crosses,” by Cassandra Carmichael, director of the eco-justice program at the National Council of Churches.

Alright, so honestly I was entirely uninterested in this chapter.  No need to explore why here, but there was one idea that caught my eye as I read… what does it mean to help people change from takers to caretakers?  How do we, people of faith or conscience with opinions and good information and a message that is, by all accounts, emergent – how do we help people move from being situated only in consumption and self-concern toward living out a sense of connection, interdependence, and necessity of immediate response?  I suppose this is “the” social justice advocacy question and not very original, but there it is.  Carmichael talks about how a community of watermen on the Chesapeake, people who’d been using those waters for their own survival suddenly experienced the literal washing up of their sins onshore when the garbage they’d been dumping rolled onto their beaches.  I suppose this is one way to bring people over from taking to care-taking, but it’s not controllable and not everyone moves easily based on shame and guilt.  I suppose my reflection and my wondering about this lead me to ask, what’s the most effective, most immediate, and most loving way to change behavior?  My instinct is that it’s not shame and it’s not just policy-creation.  What is really at the heart of sea change?  I find myself hoping that it isn’t fear.

Resistance, light shows, and other super powers.

I hate talking on the telephone.  Maybe this makes me sound anachronistic, or anti-social, or unlikeable.  I hate it.   My excuse has always been that I spent six years answering crisis calls at a rape crisis hotline and at a domestic violence shelter, where every call was guaranteed to be emotionally difficult or downright scary.  I don’t know if this is the case, but it’s a pretty decent excuse.  But, more than phone calls, I hate asking people for things.  Small things, big things, abstract things, concrete things.  Favors, things deserved and things needed.  Asking for help, for information.  It’s hard.  Part of it is likely pride.  But, thinking about some of the models I had growing up, it struck me lately that a portion of that resistance stems from not knowing what tone to strike.  Simple human interactions just seem so challenging sometimes, and the moment of request, of being vulnerable to “no,” heightens the feeling of being rather at sea in this world of people, most of whom seem to be able to interact with others with very little effort. 

I don’t know about you, but I’ve watched people my whole life, studied my classmates, colleagues, people on the street and on television, my teachers and friends.  Somewhere in my childhood, I learned the skill of reading a room.  Who is uncomfortable?  Who is the leader here?   Who’s the bully?   A good friend?  In pain?  Enjoying herself?  Most people do this, I imagine, but my sense of it comes viscerally, and usually in color, bodies and personalities subtly webbed together in my mind, a moving light show of human relationships.  The problem here is that along the way, I didn’t learn how to situate myself in the web.  I can’t read the ways I connect to others, which is where the watching comes in.  Meeting someone who does “human” well, I find myself dissecting how it is that s/he manages it, especially they wear it easily and with grace. 

You’re wondering about now… okay.  What do talking on the telephone, asking for things, and feeling connected have at all to do with one another?  Well, it seems that community organizing and the role I’ve been called to in the church require all of these skills.  I could just laugh, if it weren’t so frustrating.  During my internship this year, I’ve been commissioned with the task of building a lead team around the issue of healthcare in the West Ohio Conference parish.  I think I’ve frustrated the very soul out of my supervisor asking detailed questions about how, in fact, one goes about doing this.  She is one of those amazing people who seems to be effortless in her ability to build relationships with people, at the drop of a hat.  I’ve hemmed, and hawed, and reorganized my notes, rewritten my agenda, emailed, emailed again… but there has been a stony resistance, a nearly literal barrier between myself and making those calls.  Because… I do hate talking on the phone.  Crisis calls are easy – someone else is calling me for help, knowing that my expertise is available and focused, knowing that I am there for the sole purpose of saying “yes” to whatever they ask.  There’s little vulnerability there.  But, oh… these lead team calls.  Even to folks who’ve expressed an interest in the issue, I have to sell a product.  I have to sell myself, as a coordinator.  I have to sell the conference.  It makes me want to bite something.

So.  A couple of weeks ago, having spent some time sitting in the dark in my office, parsing out exactly why I was hating this process so much, despite the fact that I very much want it to be successful and believe in it… and, annoyed with the fact that I had let something get the better of me… I made the darn calls.  In my heart of hearts, I simply knew I would sound ridiculous, unprofessional, under-educated, young, and generally flaky.  Each person would tell me “no.”  I would fail, and paradoxically, I would be proven right – failure and success in one tight little package.  But I swallowed hard and dialed.

And had numerous lovely conversations with bright and accepting people about the state of healthcare in Ohio, its relationship to spiritual formation and simple living, and the possibilities for real change through a coalition of followers of Jesus who firmly believe that we can’t do the work of God to the best of our ability unless the bodies God gave us are cared for. 

Holy hell.  I hate to be wrong.  But sometimes, a psychological smack in the face is a good thing.  One woman, she even told me at the end of the phone call that she hadn’t been very excited about this project until she spoke with me.  Yeah.  I really giggled at that, when I hung up.  But then my little internal light show blinked like a cloud of fire-flies, and one little baby light flickered into view.  It was me.  The realization that not seeing how you fit into the greater picture is not the same thing as not being in the picture at all.   Just as our feelings that God is absent sometimes is not the same as God actually being gone… Our eyes just aren’t that well-adjusted.  We can’t see everything, and we really can’t figure out for ourselves how it all fits together.  This is what I keep thinking about as I reflect on these phone calls.  Yes, I still hate the phone.  I still really dislike asking people for things.  I still read a room and struggle to know how I fit into a group, how other people see me.  Those things will likely never change.  But they don’t have to, really.  Because I get to learn from them.  Resistance is an opportunity to figure out why we are the way we are.  Fearfully and wonderfully made, and all the junk, too.  Discomfort and anxiety, uncertainty and blindness, these are human traits, not God’s.  Not liking to talk on the phone, not connecting immediately with other people, being afraid to ask for things… just because these skills are important to the work I’ve apparently been called to do, and I don’t really have them, doesn’t negate that call.   Because I don’t have all of the information, and I’m often wrong.

I’m going to chuckle about that woman’s comment for a while yet.  All the things I think I know.  And the ways in which I have no idea what I’m talking about.  God’s probably laughing, too.

The possibilities of fear.

A friend asked me a question this morning, one of those questions that causes you to hold your breath a moment before answering.  In that split second, you size up yourself, the question, where it’s coming from, the possible consequences of answering it honestly or of being flippant or diplomatic.  Have you ever been asked a question like this?  One that makes you wonder whether honesty is the best policy… or whether you’re about to say something even you are not quite ready to know about yourself, let alone share with another human being? 

I confess that I’ve often prided myself on being afraid of pretty much nothing.  I think risks are important, and trust is something God and I work on together every day, so it’s the two of us together pushing me to do things that make me feel challenged or uncomfortable or horrified or stretched, to grow the edges of my self out into a more Jules-shaped form, to strain against the space and categories I’ve tried to create to keep myself safe.  I’ve learned over time that fear isn’t a bad thing, necessarily – it’s a warning, a caution, a help.  It can also paralyze, constrain, and cripple the soul if allowed to master you.  Sometimes, I’ve let it do that. 

She asked me, “Random: are you afraid of anything, and if so, would you be willing to tell me what?”  It came out of pretty much nowhere: “random” is the perfect word.  But it’s randomness made me actually sit and think about it seriously, wonder how important my answer might actually be, without context, without possibility for shaping it, without extensive reflection.  So I answered on instinct.  And scared myself.  What am I afraid of?  Well, sharks, for one thing.  Those are some creepy creatures, and I have a deep respect for them.  Falling and breaking my elbow is another.  Knives.  But those are human fears, situated in genes and the very fact of being an animal in a world of natural danger.  Peeling back those fears, looking farther inside myself, I found that there is something very sharp and hard inside of me, a fear that rides me hard and, sometimes for my good and at other times for my harm, shapes who I am. 

I’m afraid that I’m settling for being the best where I am, rather than taking a risk of being less than the best in the place I’m supposed to be. 

Until recently, I wouldn’t have articulated it this way.  Another friend helped me think this through earlier this week, though not from the same perspective.  The problem of being afraid has come up over and over again for me during the last year, for various reasons, some of them related to the painful emergence from the protection of graduate school into the real world, some based in personal relationships whose broken places have only recently become evident, some related to the constant, necessary reflection about my purpose in life that happens during faith development. 

But the question keeps turning up: can I, should I, step over the edge into something new and infinitely more difficult, definitely unknown, where I may fail extravegantly and painfully but where, perhaps, I might also flourish and find nourishment, grace, challenge, and beautiful fulfilment of my potential?  Or can I, should I, stay the course and be the best of me where I am right now, growing into that place and doing the respectable and important work of trusting that this, too, is good… is perhaps exactly where I am supposed to be?  Both feel risky.  Both feel permanent.  These are options, possibilities, choices, that will continually arise throughout my life.  Neither is obviously better or worse than the other, depending on what it is I decide I value.  But I have to know what those values are.  I am afraid.  And I was honest with my friend.  Now I have to be honest with myself and decide whether to step left, step right, or stand right where I am and camp out.  Then, harder yet, I will have to trust that it was the right choice, made in faith.

Just put on some angels.

Last night I decided to take a sabbath, which included such deeply spiritually-forming activities as drinking cans of coke while buffing my nails and watching three consecutive episodes of “House.”  So sue me.  As I was flipping between shows and considering my next move, I stopped briefly at QVC.  At first, I was drawn in by the crazy headband the host of the show was wearing (black with silver sequins, but most oddly, it wrapped around her forehead with a bow in the back.  I’d never seen such a thing before).  But it was what she said that kept me there.  As she and the other shiny, well-dressed, polished saleswoman attempted to convince me to buy a high-quality sweater covered with appliques of poinsettias and angels, she made this compelling claim, which I can’t claim to quote verbatim, though I think I”ve mostly remembered it:

“In this time when we’re all so scared… the world seems scary.  There’s an economic crisis in our hearts.  But here’s this sweater, and it’s got angels on it.  Isn’t it pretty?  If we all just cover ourselves with angels, we’ll realize that there’s really no problem, it’s in our minds.  The angels protect us.  So buy this sweater and feel better immediately.  We all need something pretty when things seem hard.”

You’re reading that and saying to yourself, “Come on, Jules.  That’s not what she said.  No one could possibly think a) something so stupid or b) that will sell sweaters.”  But I’m not pulling your chain.  And I’m not exaggerating, either.  That was her message. 

I sat and watched my shows and thought about this, attempting to break it down.  Let’s reason through: first, what kind of world does this woman live in that she would want to make this statement?  Well, of course she’s  a salesperson, so there’s the issue of saying whatever it might take to sell product.  But people must respond, this must speak to folks.  After all, QVC is successful (though they are laying off folks right now, like many other businesses during this recession).  It’s not exactly a message of fear, like those we’ve heard in the political realm for the last decade and which seem to be less and less attractive to people.  Rather, it’s a word of avoidance, a gospel of spiritualism.  Sort of a “click your heels together and say ‘there’s no place like home’” hope.  Are we so afraid at this point that we have moved from resistance to curling up in a little ball, covering ourselves in warm blankets, and waiting out the storm, hoping our guardian angels are watching over us? 

I confess, sometimes this seems like the best answer.  After all, there I was, avoiding the news, my own personal difficulties, the hardships of the world by exiting reality for a few hours, entering a world of pretty things and junk food and the TV-world where the doctors always figure out what’s wrong and fix it by the end of the hour.  But is there a difference between, a healthy version of (even), escapism and taking a break?  I personally don’t think we can survive without some sort of escape, but the idea that we can solve our problems by purchasing clothing is ridiculous and dangerous.  More disturbingly, it’s the message we all hear nearly every day.  We are no longer citizens, just consumers.  That’s the world we live in right now.  Our fear prevents us from acting wisely and well.  Instead, we just put on some angels.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.